We are operating at reduced capacity due to COVID-19 Alert Level Three restrictions in Auckland. Please only call our 0800 number if someone is at serious risk of harm or has been seriously injured, become seriously ill, or died as a result of work.
This is a quick guide with advice for workers about what bullying at work can look like, and what they can do if they think they are being bullied, or are accused of being a bully.
1. What is this guide about?
Bullying harms workers. A worker’s business or undertaking (the person conducting a business or undertaking – PCBU) must ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the health and safety of workers, and that other persons are not put at risk by its work.
The business or undertaking must, so far as is reasonably practicable, minimise the likelihood of bullying by putting in place control measures such as having a code of conduct, reporting procedures for unreasonable behaviour and manager training.
See our good practice guidelines Preventing and Responding to Bullying at Work [PDF, 897 KB] for examples of possible control measures.
While the business or undertaking must effectively deal with bullying at work, everyone at work has a role in dealing with it.
This is a quick guide with advice for workers about what bullying at work can look like, and what they can do if they think they are being bullied, or are accused of being a bully.
You should take opportunities such as worker surveys and focus groups to let your business or undertaking know if the control measures are working to minimise the likelihood of bullying at your workplace.
2. Bullying at work
What is workplace bullying?
How can bullying harm workers?
Bullying harms workers. Bullying can affect the health and well-being of workers as described in Figure 2.
When can bullying happen?
Bullying can happen at any time and at all levels of a business or undertaking.
- isn’t limited to managers targeting staff or staff targeting managers – it can also happen between co-workers, and between workers and other people at workplaces such as clients, customers or visitors
- can occur when, because of how an organisation operates, behaviour is allowed to occur that offends or unduly stresses or unreasonably burdens workers without concern for their well-being (eg unrealistic deadlines)
- can be carried out by one or more persons
- can be directed at a single person or a group
- may occur outside normal work hours.
Bullying can be carried out in a variety of ways including through email, text messaging, internet chat rooms or other social media channels (called cyberbullying).
For further information on cyberbullying, see NetSafe’s website(external link).
What kind of behaviours can be perceived as bullying?
There are different types of bullying and types of bullying behaviours.
Bullying can be physical, verbal or relational/social (eg excluding someone from a peer group, spreading rumours).1
Common bullying behaviours fit in two main categories:
- attacks that are direct and personal or
- indirect and task-related.
Examples of these behaviours are described in Table 1.
Some of these behaviours may also fall under other types of behaviour such as discrimination or violence.
If you consider that the behaviour you are experiencing is bullying or other unreasonable behaviour, go to Section 3 of this guide for what you could do.
Personal attacks (direct) - examples include:
|Task-related attacks (indirect) - examples include:|
|Belittling remarks – undermining integrity – lies being told – sense of judgment questioned – opinions marginalised||Giving unachievable tasks – impossible deadlines – unmanageable workloads – overloading – ‘setting up to fail’|
|Ignoring – excluding – silent treatment – isolating||Meaningless tasks – unpleasant jobs – belittling a person’s ability – undermining|
|Attacking a person’s beliefs, attitude, lifestyle or appearance – gender references – accusations of being mentally disturbed||Withholding or concealing information – information goes missing – failing to return calls or pass on messages|
|Ridiculing – insulting – teasing – jokes – ‘funny surprises’ – sarcasm||Undervaluing contribution – no credit where it’s due – taking credit for work that’s not their own|
|Being shouted or yelled at||Constant criticism of work|
|Threats of violence||Underwork – working below competence – removing responsibility – demotion|
|Insulting comments about private life||Unreasonable or inappropriate monitoring|
|Physical attacks||Offensive sanctions (eg denying leave where there is no reason to do so)|
|Humiliation (in public or private)||Excluding – isolating – ignoring views|
|Persistent and/or public criticism||Changing goalposts or targets|
|Using obscene or offensive language, gestures, material||Not giving enough training or resources|
|Ganging up – colleagues/clients encouraged to criticise or spy – witch hunt – dirty tricks campaign – singled out||Reducing opportunities for expression – interrupting when speaking|
|Intimidation – acting in a condescending manner||Supplying incorrect or unclear information|
|Intruding on privacy (eg spying, stalking, harassed by calls when on leave or at weekends)||Making hints or threats about job security|
|Unwanted sexual approaches, offers, or physical contact||No support from manager|
|Inaccurate accusations||Denial of opportunity|
|Suggestive glances, gestures, or dirty looks||Judging wrongly|
|Tampering with personal effects – theft – destruction of property||Forced or unjustified disciplinary hearings|
|Encouraged to feel guilty||Lack of role clarity|
Table 1: Examples of bullying behaviours2
3. What are your options if you think you are being bullied or experiencing other unreasonable behaviour?
Note: All current or prospective workers are legally protected from discrimination and dismissal by a PCBU (adverse conduct) for carrying out health and safety-related activities or raising health and safety issues or concerns. See our special guide Introduction to Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 [PDF, 640 KB] for further information.
You have a number of options available to you as described below.
For each incident keep records of:
- the date, time and where it occurred
- what happened (who was present, what was said, who said what)
- if there were any witnesses
- how you felt.
Work out what to do
You could take one or more of the options in Figure 3.
Mediation can be used early on in the situation or at other times (eg after an investigation). Both parties should request and freely agree to take part in mediation.
Mediation involves a trained and impartial mediator sitting with all parties concerned to try to get an agreement and a way forward. It’s important that mediation creates a safe and constructive environment. If there are genuine safety concerns, parties should inform the mediator before the mediation begins.
What should happen when you submit a report or complaint?
When you submit a report or complaint, the business or undertaking should:3
- take reasonable steps to protect you from reprisals
- ensure both you and the subject of the complaint are supported
- decide what interim measures will be taken to ensure your safety and welfare during any investigation. Interim measures may include suspension of the subject of the complaint pending the outcome of an investigation, or reassignment to other duties until an investigation is complete
- give guidance to you about how to respond to the subject of the complaint if you remain in day-to-day contact.
What should happen if an investigation occurs?
Investigations should be carried out by independent and unbiased investigators.
Table 2 outlines the principles that the business or undertaking should consider when dealing with allegations of bullying. These principles are based in part on the principles of natural justice. Natural justice covers both parties to a complaint.
The investigator should interview all parties involved and any witnesses, and review any relevant documentation to determine the facts. They will provide a written report on their findings and recommended solutions to the business or undertaking. The subject of the complaint should be given reasonable opportunity to respond to the allegations/concerns.
The business or undertaking should meet with you and the subject of the complaint separately to discuss the recommended solution.
You should receive a copy of the report and told about your right to appeal and what the process to do this is.
The final decisions and actions should be reported back to you (taking into account the privacy of the subject of the complaint). You should be told of what your business or undertaking’s processes are if you are unhappy with the final decision.
What role can Health and Safety Representatives (HSRs) have in dealing with bullying?
HSRs can help their business or undertaking to develop its bullying policies and procedures, and advise workers on them. HSRs can help you to report bullying including:
- by telling you how to make a report or
- submitting a report on your behalf (with your permission).
HSRs do not need to resolve the matter themselves, but can help to support workers that are parties to a complaint. To avoid conflicts of interest, the same HSR should not support the people on both sides of a complaint.
Ideally HSRs should be trained to provide this kind of support.
|Principle||What does it mean?|
|Treat all matters seriously||
Support all parties
|Communicate the process and outcomes||
|Maintain privacy (confidentiality)||
|Keep good documentation||
Table 2: General principles for how businesses or undertakings should deal with reports or complaints
4. Who can help?
Bullying complaints may be dealt with by different Government bodies depending on the circumstances. If you are not satisfied by the business or undertakings’ actions, and have made reasonable efforts to try to resolve the issue using internal processes, you may decide to seek external help.
In addition, certain behaviour should be dealt with externally in the first instance, for example, physical assault should be dealt with by the Police.
There is a range of legislation and external help available depending upon what type of bullying occurs:
The Employment Relations Act 2000 (ERA)
- The ERA aims to build productive employment (eg employer/employee) relationships.
- The ERA outlines penalties for certain breaches of duty of good faith within an employment relationship. Repeated verbal or emotional attacks on an employee may breach the duty of good faith – where parties to an employment relationship are required to be active and constructive in maintaining an employment relationship.
- If the employee has resigned as a result of the employer’s failure, they may be able to raise a personal grievance for unjustified dismissal or constructive dismissal. If they haven’t resigned, they may still be able to claim unjustified disadvantage under the ERA, as well as breach of contract. Employees that feel that bullying behaviour led to their unjustified disadvantage or unjustified dismissal might raise a personal grievance.
- In terms of harassment, the ERA only provides protection from sexual and racial harassment, which is also covered by the Human Rights Act 1993 (HRA)(external link). This gives grounds for a personal grievance under the ERA, or a claim under the HRA.
- MBIE’s free mediation service(external link) (Phone 0800 20 90 20;) is available to any employer or employee and can help parties resolve an employment relationship problem. The mediation service is available to assist as soon as an issue arises, and may arrange to facilitate a meeting, with the agreement of both parties.
- If mediation is unsuccessful, the Employment Relations Authority(external link) can resolve disputes about a range of employment issues (including treatment that employees find unfair or unreasonable) such as:
- payment of wages
- personal grievances for unjustified disadvantage
- personal grievances for unjustified dismissal
- being asked to do work that would expose the worker to a serious health and safety risk arising from immediate or imminent exposure to a hazard (workers can refuse such work under section 83 of HSWA). An unreasonable management decision may be an instruction to undertake unsafe work.
- Like the Employment Relations Authority, the Employment Court(external link) deals with cases about employment disputes. The Employment Court also deals with challenges to Employment Relations Authority decisions.
The Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 (HSWA)
- HSWA is the primary work health and safety legislation.
- WorkSafe is the primary work health and safety regulator - although Maritime New Zealand and the Civil Aviation Authority also carry out certain health and safety functions for their industries.
- HSWA requires certain health and safety matters to be notified to WorkSafe. People may also contact WorkSafe voluntarily if they have a question or request about health and safety, or want to tell WorkSafe about a health and safety concern.
- WorkSafe prioritises incoming notifications, requests, concerns and enquiries using risk-based processes and criteria.
- WorkSafe has a range of possible responses that are suitable for health and safety matters of different levels of seriousness, urgency and risk. Please note that not all concerns and notifications will meet WorkSafe’s threshold for initiating a response.
- WorkSafe can be contacted on 0800 030 040 (24 hours). Issues can be raised anonymously or in confidence.
The Harmful Digital Communications Act 2015 (HDCA)
- The purpose of the HDCA is to deter, prevent and mitigate harm caused to individuals by digital communications. Harm means serious emotional distress.
- The HDCA aims to provide a quick, efficient and relatively cheap legal avenue for people dealing with serious or repeated harmful digital communications.
- The HDCA lays out 10 communication principles which are plain expressions of unacceptable ways to communicate online.
- Harmful communications could include people using phones to send threatening or offensive messages, publishing threatening or offensive messages online, spreading damaging or degrading rumours and publishing invasive or distressing photographs or videos. This covers cyberbullying.
- Digital communications means any form of electronic communication and includes emails, texts, websites, blogs, comments sections, online forums (chat rooms), social media sites, or phone apps.
- The HDCA simplifies the process for taking harmful communications off the internet quickly, and has criminal and civil sanctions.
- For information about what to do if you are experiencing cyberbullying, online harassment and abuse, visit NetSafe's website(external link).
- Before applying to the Courts, you must have had your complaint investigated by NetSafe.
- For information on how to apply to the Court, visit the Victims Information website(external link).
The Human Rights Act 1993 (HRA)
- Discrimination can be part of bullying.
- Discrimination occurs when a person is treated unfairly or less favourable than another person in the same or similar circumstances.
- The HRA’s intention is to ensure everyone is treated fairly and equally.
- The HRA makes it illegal to discriminate on the grounds of:
- marital status
- religious belief
- ethical belief
- colour, race, or ethnic or national origins
- political opinion
- employment status
- family status
- sexual orientation.
- It also covers sexual and racial harassment at work, school and other areas.
- The Human Rights Commission(external link) deals with complaints about discrimination.
Harassment Act 1997 (HA)
- Harassment can be part of bullying.
- Harassment takes place when someone engages in a pattern of behaviour that is directed against another person (including watching, loitering, following, accosting, interfering with another person’s property or acting in ways that causes the person to fear for their safety) at least twice in a 12-month period.
- The HA makes harassment a criminal offence in certain circumstances. It provides for restraining orders. See the ERA and HRA above for dealing with racial and sexual harassment.
- Harassment has the potential to cause humiliation, offence or intimidation. It’s usually repeated behaviour but even one instance may cause reasonable concern.
- People who are being harassed may be able to obtain restraining orders against the person harassing them. Help may be found at organisations such as community law centres(external link) and the Citizens Advice Bureau(external link).
Crimes Act 1961 and other legislation administered by the New Zealand Police
- Acts of violence towards a person can be verbal (verbal abuse, threats, shouting, swearing) or physical (stalking, throwing objects, hitting, damage to property).
- Violence is illegal and should be referred to the Police.
- Criminal charges can be filed by the Police.
5. What should you do if you are accused of being a bully?
If you are accused of bullying, you should take the complaint seriously.
You should be informed as soon as possible after a complaint has been received.
You could also be the subject of a formal investigation. See Section 3 of this guide for information about investigations.
You should expect to be notified about:
- the details of the complaint and who made it (eg details of the allegations, including a copy of the written complaint and any investigation material)
- the process and your rights (including the right to have a support person present)
- the requirement for confidentiality and non-victimisation
- the possible consequences (eg if it’s a formal employment investigation that could result in dismissal)
- expectations of behaviour during any investigation (to remain professional).
- interim measures will be taken to ensure the safety and welfare of the person who complained during any investigation. Interim measures may include your suspension pending the outcome of any investigation, or reassignment to other duties until any investigation is complete.
You should consider what has been said, and how the person making the complaint about you might be feeling/thinking to have made this complaint.
You can seek advice and support from others such as managers, colleagues, Health and Safety Representatives (HSRs), your union, your local Community Law Centre or Citizens Advice Bureau, an employee assistance programme (if available), helplines (see Section 7 of this guide), or the Human Resources team. To avoid conflicts of interest, the same support person should not support the people on both sides of a complaint.
6. What should you do if you see bullying?
Bystanders (people that see bullying occurring) can have an important role when dealing with bullying.
When they feel safe to, bystanders could use words and actions to safely and effectively help someone being bullied (eg speak up when you see unreasonable behaviour).
Bystanders can also report bullying on someone else’s behalf.
7. Glossary and where to find more information
|Term||Explanation or legal definition (as noted)|
|Persons conducting a business or undertaking (PCBUs)||
A PCBU is a ‘person conducting a business or undertaking’. A PCBU may be an individual person or an organisation. This does not include workers or officers of PCBUs (to the extent they are solely workers or officers), volunteer associations (that do not have employees), or home occupiers that employ or engage a tradesperson to carry out residential work.
A PCBU must ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the health and safety of workers, and that other persons are not put at risk by its work.
PCBUs must, so far as is reasonably practicable, minimise the likelihood of bullying by putting in place control measures.
PCBUs must provide information, training, instruction or supervision needed to protect all people from health and safety risks from the work being carried out.
A worker is an individual who carries out work in any capacity for a PCBU. A worker may be an employee, a contractor or sub-contractor, an employee of a contractor or sub-contractor, an employee of a labour hire company, an outworker (including a homeworker), an apprentice or a trainee, a person gaining work experience or on a work trial, or a volunteer worker. It also includes an individual PCBU that carries out work for the business or undertaking.
Workers can be at any level (eg managers are workers too).
Workers have duties to take reasonable care to keep themselves and others healthy and safe when carrying out work.
Workers must co-operate with reasonable policies and procedures about bullying the PCBU has in place that have been notified to them.
Workers must comply, so far as is reasonably practicable, with any reasonable instruction about bullying given by the PCBU so the PCBU can comply with the law.
|Other persons at workplaces such as visitors||
Examples of other persons at workplaces include workplace visitors, casual volunteers at workplaces and customers.
Other persons have duties to take reasonable care for their own health and safety and to take reasonable care that they don’t harm others at a workplace.
They must comply, so far as is reasonably practicable, with any reasonable instruction about bullying given by the PCBU so the PCBU can comply with the law.
For more information about dealing with bullying at work see WorkSafe’s good practice guidelines Preventing and Responding to Bullying at Work. The www.worksafe.govt.nz website will also have tools that you may find useful.
Advice may be found from places like:
- community law centres(external link)
- the Citizens Advice Bureau(external link)
- employee assistance programs (if available at your workplace)
- helplines such as: Lifeline 0800 543 354, Samaritans 0800 726 666 and Healthline 0800 611 116. For more information, visit the Mental Health Foundation website(external link).
- NetSafe (for cyberbullying)(external link)
- Human Rights Commission (for complaints about discrimination)(external link)
3 - If your business or undertaking does not have a report or complaint form to fill out, visit bullying: forms for one you can use.